Can I Eat Expired Homemade Eggnog?
There's nothing quite like the creamy richness of homemade eggnog to make the holidays feel special, but with its raw eggs and dairy, safety is key. To fully savor this festive delight, remember to store it in the fridge and enjoy within three days—because while it’s a beloved tradition, food safety shouldn’t take a backseat!
Not safe to eat after expiry
Expert Source
"According to USDA guidelines, homemade eggnog should be stored in the refrigerator at 40°F or below and consumed within 2 hours if left at room temperature, or within 2 days if stored in the refrigerator."
✅Fresh Homemade Eggnog

⚠️Spoiled Homemade Eggnog

Storage Guidelines
Storage Location
Fridge
Ideal Temperature
34-40°F (1-4°C)
Best Storage Method
Store in airtight container. Keep refrigerated at all times. Do not leave at room temperature.
Shelf Life
Average Shelf Life
3 days
Signs of Spoilage
Separation, off odor, unusual texture, sour smell
Additional Information
Alternative Uses
Baking, coffee flavoring
Possible Substitutions
Commercial eggnog, holiday beverages
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between expiration and best quality dates?
▼
The expiration date of homemade eggnog is typically around 2-3 days due to the presence of raw eggs and dairy products. After this time, the eggnog may start to spoil and pose a higher risk of foodborne illness. The best quality of eggnog is within the first day of preparation when the flavors are fresh and the texture is creamy. As time passes, the eggnog may separate or develop off-flavors. It is important to discard any eggnog that has an off smell, taste, or appearance.
How can I tell if Homemade Eggnog has gone bad?
▼
To determine if Homemade Eggnog has gone bad, check for any signs of curdling, separation, or chunkiness in its texture. Additionally, a sour or off smell indicates spoilage. Mold or unusual discoloration are visual indicators that the eggnog should be thrown away.
What are the food safety risks?
▼
Homemade eggnog poses a risk of foodborne illness if not handled and stored properly. The main concern is the use of raw eggs in traditional recipes, as they can potentially contain harmful bacteria such as Salmonella. To reduce this risk, it is recommended to use pasteurized eggs or egg products in your eggnog recipe. Additionally, ensure that the eggnog is refrigerated promptly after preparation and consumed within a few days to minimize the growth of bacteria.
What are some pro storage tips?
▼
To store homemade eggnog properly, it should be refrigerated at all times at a temperature below 40°F (4°C). Store the eggnog in a tightly sealed container to prevent contamination and absorption of other food odors. If you want to prolong the shelf life of eggnog, you can freeze it for up to 3 months. Before serving frozen eggnog, thaw it in the refrigerator overnight and give it a good stir to recombine any separated ingredients. Avoid refreezing previously frozen eggnog to maintain quality.
Any interesting facts about Homemade Eggnog?
▼
Eggnog has a long history and is often associated with holiday celebrations in Western cultures, particularly in North America and Europe. It is believed to have originated in medieval Europe as a rich, creamy drink made with milk, eggs, and spices. Eggnog was traditionally consumed to toast to good health and prosperity. In the United States, eggnog is commonly enjoyed during the winter holidays, especially around Christmas and New Year's Eve.
Can I store Homemade Eggnog in a glass jar instead of a plastic container?
▼
Yes, you can store Homemade Eggnog in a glass jar instead of a plastic container. Glass containers are preferred for storing eggnog as they are non-reactive and help maintain the flavor. Ensure the jar has a tight-sealing lid to prevent contamination and extend the shelf life.
How does refrigerating affect the texture of Homemade Eggnog compared to leaving it at room temperature?
▼
Refrigerating Homemade Eggnog helps maintain its creamy texture and prevents rapid bacterial growth, unlike leaving it at room temperature. Room temperature storage can lead to quicker spoilage and a separation of ingredients in the eggnog. Always refrigerate Homemade Eggnog promptly.
Can Homemade Eggnog be safely transported for a 2-hour car ride?
▼
When transporting Homemade Eggnog for a 2-hour car ride, use a cooler with ice packs to keep it chilled below 40°F (4°C) to prevent bacterial growth. Avoid placing the eggnog in direct sunlight or near heat sources in the car. Once you reach your destination, refrigerate it promptly.
How does adding alcohol to Homemade Eggnog affect its shelf life compared to the non-alcoholic version?
▼
Adding alcohol to Homemade Eggnog can actually extend its shelf life due to the preservative properties of alcohol. The non-alcoholic version typically has a shelf life of 3 days in the fridge, while the alcoholic version can last up to a week. However, always check for signs of spoilage before consuming.
Does Homemade Eggnog last longer in winter compared to summer?
▼
Homemade Eggnog tends to last longer in winter than in summer due to cooler ambient temperatures. Hotter temperatures can accelerate bacterial growth, shortening the shelf life of eggnog. To prolong its freshness, store Homemade Eggnog in the coldest part of the fridge, away from temperature fluctuations.
Can I consume Homemade Eggnog that has been left out at a holiday party for 2 hours?
▼
If Homemade Eggnog has been left out at a holiday party for 2 hours, it's best to discard it to avoid the risk of foodborne illness. Eggnog should be kept refrigerated below 40°F (4°C) to prevent the growth of harmful bacteria. When in doubt, prioritize food safety and avoid consuming potentially hazardous eggnog.
How does the type of spice used in Homemade Eggnog affect its flavor and shelf life?
▼
The type of spice used in Homemade Eggnog can impact its flavor profile but does not significantly affect its shelf life. Common spices like nutmeg, cinnamon, or cloves add distinctive tastes to eggnog but do not alter its storage requirements. Store spiced eggnog in the fridge and consume within 3 days for optimal quality.
Can Homemade Eggnog be safely consumed if it was accidentally left out overnight?
▼
If Homemade Eggnog has been left out overnight, it is not safe to consume. Bacteria can multiply rapidly at room temperature, increasing the risk of foodborne illness. Discard any eggnog that has been left unrefrigerated for an extended period to protect your health.
Expiration Calculator
Sources
For more information on food safety and expiration guidelines, visit our Sources page.
Scan your food directly and get instant safety info using our AI-powered camera feature.
Similar Storage Requirements
Cooked Angel Hair Pasta
Grains & Pasta
View expiration date and storage guide →
Parsley
Herbs and Fresh Produce
View expiration date and storage guide →
Lamb Chops All Cuts Including Shoulder Loin Rib Fresh Raw
Meat & Poultry
View expiration date and storage guide →
Basil Fresh
Herbs and Fresh Produce
View expiration date and storage guide →
Cooked Egg Yolks
Dairy Products
View expiration date and storage guide →
Fresh Apples Cut
Fruits & Vegetables
View expiration date and storage guide →
Bel Paese Cheese
Dairy Products
View expiration date and storage guide →
Halibut Fresh Raw
Seafood
View expiration date and storage guide →
Duck Whole Fresh Raw
Meat & Poultry
View expiration date and storage guide →
Reviewed By: Food Safety & Expiration Experts
At Can I Eat Expired, we are committed to providing accurate, science-backed information about food expiration and storage safety. Our content is carefully reviewed based on guidelines from leading food safety organizations, including:
- ✅U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) – Food Safety Guidelines
- ✅United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) – Food Storage & Expiration Dates
- ✅World Health Organization (WHO) – Foodborne Diseases & Safety
- ✅Centers for Disease Control & Prevention (CDC) – Preventing Foodborne Illness
🔍 How We Ensure Accuracy
- We use official food safety sources to guide our recommendations.
- Our team continuously reviews and updates content based on the latest research.
- We encourage users to always check for signs of spoilage and follow proper storage guidelines.
📚 Have Questions?
If you have specific concerns about food expiration or safety, we recommend consulting a registered dietitian, food scientist, or your local health department.
Note: These are general guidelines. Always use your best judgment and when in doubt, throw it out.